01.01.2015 00:00
->
->
On this they write in the “Twitter”. People took refuge inside a large herringbone ball that installed on the square for the holiday. Police for several hours on their presence does not respond.
I recall the night before several thousand people gathered at the Manege Square and the surrounding streets to protest against the verdict brothers Navalny. The police, according to the portal “ATS-Info” detained 250 people, including Alexei Navalny.
The apartment politics last night several police officers were on duty, passed from the scene correspondent of “Echo of Moscow”. In the “Twitter” Navalny there was a record that the police blocked the entrance to the courtyard of his house. In FSIN reported that fixed abnormality and notify the court.
eve Zamoskvoretskiy court sentenced the politician to 3.5 years probation and left under house arrest. His brother Oleg got a real period of 3.5 years. After that, Alex broke the chosen measure of restraint and tried to lead a protest action at the Manege Square. However, he was detained at the approaches to the place of action.
The European Union and the US State Department commented on the sentence Alexei Navalny and his brother Oleg imposed on “business Ives Rosher”: it was considered to be politically motivated, unjust, and the continuing harassment of political minorities and civil society.
The European Union policy to explain the verdict. “A guilty verdict today … in respect of Alexei Navalny and his brother Oleg Navalny, apparently, was politically motivated,” – said the press representative of the head of European diplomacy Federica Mogherini Maya Kosyanchich. She pointed out that the allegations “were not substantiated in the trial” and urged the courts to act independently, free from political interference and guided solely by the rule of law, reports DW .
State Department charges commented the spokesman Jeff Rathke. During the daily Briefing for journalists, he said that the US “concerned” disturbing developments and consider the verdict as another step to punish political activists and “independent voices”. “We remain concerned about the increasing restrictions of independent media, civil society, minorities and political opposition. We believe that people in Russia, as elsewhere, deserve a government that supports the free exchange of ideas, transparent and accountable governance, equitable application of the law and the ability to exercise their rights without fear of punishment, “- said Rathke.
The verdict also criticized the human rights commissioner Germany Christoph Shtreser, stressing that this is another blow to civil society in Russia.
Zamoskvoretskiy court in Moscow on Tuesday announced the verdict oppositionist Alexei Navalny and his brother Oleg, accused of embezzling company funds and Yves Rocher “Multidisciplinary processing company.” Both helper convicted. Alexei Navalny sentenced to three years and six months probation in three years. His brother Oleg was 3.5 years imprisonment in a penal colony.
Initially, the verdict should have announced on January 15th. However, as it became known yesterday, due to the fact that Judge Elena Korobchenko written verdict before the date of the announcement was moved to December 30.
During a protest in central Moscow on Manezh Square and around it detained about 300 people , including Alexei Navalny, violated the rules of house arrest and came into the city center. Most were released about 70 spend the night in various ATS capital.
Related Links:
Catalog NEWSru.com:
Information Internet resources
Dossier NEWSru.com:
parties and politicians // // Society Navalny, Alexey
Photo: AP
The judge of the court of the capital Zamoskvoreche Elena Korobchenko announced the verdict in the case” Yves Rocher “. Oleg and Alexei Navalny found guilty of embezzling company funds. Oleg Navalny was 3.5 years a penal colony, and his brother, opposition leader Alexei Navalny – the same term is conditional, the correspondent of RBC from the courtroom.
In addition, Alexei Navalny fined 500 thousand. Rubles . The politician yet remain under house arrest – as explained RBC Press Secretary Cyrus Yarmish Navalny, this preventive measure will be effective until the sentence comes into force. “An appeal may appoint and April», – Yarmish reported. While she could not say what conclusions do policies of his brother’s arrest: “We have not talked to him about it.” Bulk brothers also have to pay 4.5 million rubles. IPC company.
Immediately after the verdict Oleg Navalny was taken into custody. He will be placed in jail and will be there until the sentence to the effect.
Alexei Navalny left the courthouse at 10:20, stating that unhappy verdict and urged his supporters to take part in the protests.
The verdict took a few minutes, the judge Elena Korobchenko read out only the introductory and the operative part of the judgment.
The protection will appeal the verdict. As explained by RBC lawyer Vadim Kobzev, the judge in sentencing reclassified the charges against ordinary fraud (Article 159 of the Criminal Code), a softer composition – fraud in business (Article 159.4 of the Criminal Code). As a result, the court appointed a lighter sentence.
The defense Navalny has ten days to appeal the sentence. If the court’s decision will be appealed, the sentence will come into force only after the appeal.
Prosecutors during the pleadings requested Alexei Navalny sentenced to ten years imprisonment, and Oleg – to eight years, as well as to recover with them 4.5 million rubles. in favor of the IPC. Initially, the judge sentenced the brothers Navalny Elena Korobchenko planned to announce on January 15th. A new date for sentencing court announced just a day before its announcement.
In this case, the French company “Yves Rocher East”, which is considered the main victim in the case, has not filed any claims, and its representatives left the question of guilt Navalny on discretion of the court. The investigation also estimated their losses at 26.7 million rubles.
In court, prosecutors insisted that the brothers Bulk developed criminal plan: set up front companies “Glavpodpiska”, the founder of which was a Cypriot company, and was appointed director of the familiar Dmitry Zaprudskaya.
According to investigators, Oleg Navalny, using his position to “Russian Post” concluded contracts for delivery of goods company “Yves Rocher Vostok” and the IPC. Delivery of goods also engaged in transport companies, which the defendant hired at a price lower than the company-paid victims. During the trial, the company said IPC civil lawsuit in the amount of 4.5 million rubles. “Yves Rocher East”, in turn, no property claims are not stated, and the question of guilt brothers left to the discretion of the court.
Bulk themselves insisted that did not commit any crimes. According to his brother, “Glavpodpiska” was created for the organization of periodical subscriptions via the Internet. But the service did not demand. Therefore, Alexei Navalny gave the company to his brother, who began to use it at their own discretion – to organize the transport of goods. The defendants argued that the company was engaged in ordinary course of business.
Their version of the court confirmed and employees of companies-victims. So, the director of “Yves Rocher East» Logistics Sergey Averyanov and logistics manager Dmitry Vas’kov argued that “Glavpodpiska” not harmed their company: the price of shipping goods were market, and provides professional services.
Leaders of the IPC, in turn, argued in court that the fact that they suffer damage, they were told investigators.
Alexei Navalny already has two convictions. In July 2013, he and Peter officers were sentenced to five and four years’ imprisonment respectively for the “case Kirovlesa.” Then they were taken into custody in the courtroom. But the very next day they released the Kirov regional court at the request of prosecutors. Later the sentence was changed to conditional. The second sentence against Navalny delivered Babushkinskiy Magistrate’s Court, finding him guilty of defaming the deputy Alexei Lisovenko for what politician on Twitter Hosting Project l victim addict.
“At the heart of the European Court of Human Rights in the Yukos case are legal mistakes, they call into question Russia’s recognition of the decision,” – According to RIA Novosti, so says the Minister of Justice Alexander Konovalov. In its opinion, the Court made as exceeding its jurisdiction, and a significant departure from its own case-law. Ministry of Justice and the previously stated their disagreement with the decision of the European Court of Yukos.
Zamoskovoretsky Moscow court has sentenced the oppositionist Alexei Navalny and his brother Oleg in the case of embezzlement in the company “Yves Rocher”. Alexei Navalny was three and a half year suspended sentence and a fine of 500 thousand. Oleg Navalny was sentenced to three and a half years in a penal colony and a fine of 500 thousand rubles.
The original sentencing was scheduled for January 15th. On the transfer date became known yesterday. At the courthouse, where the verdict filled the brothers Navalny, were strengthened security measures. Radio Liberty correspondents were live video.
After the transfer on December 30 the verdict brothers Alex and Oleg Navalny on Facebook there was a group whose members gather tonight to “discuss the court’s decision.” The so-called “People’s Assembly” at the Manege Square in Moscow are ready to go more than 10 thousand people.
The surname “Bulk” the majority of Russians, learn about the latest developments of the central television news programs, first heard at the end of 2011. In related news, it was then represented by one of the leaders of the protest movement that emerged in the wake of discontent fraud in the Duma elections and inspiration “network hamsters” .
In RuNet about Alexei Navalny talking a few years earlier. His blog “Live Journal” (now locked Roscomnadzor) began to attract hundreds of subscribers in 2008, when Navalny, having bought small stakes in major Russian companies, engaged in “Invest activism.” “Kommersant”, for example, wrote at the time that Alexei Navalny is the holder of shares of “Rosneft”, “Gazprom”, “Lukoil”, “Surgutneftegaz”, “Gazprom Neft”, “Transneft”, TNK-BP and VTB Bank and a minority shareholder requires management of these companies disclose information about the activities of management, which affects the income of shareholders and corporate transparency.
After a while started and lawsuits. The initiators of some acted very Navalny, seek to prosecute corrupt officials and senior managers of state companies. Others become initiators officials demanding protection of honor and dignity, or the state in the face of law enforcement officers who spotted in the activities of the crime Alexei Navalny. Currently Zamoskvoretskiy District Court of Moscow is considering the second criminal case against Navalny. The verdict in the first involving allegations of embezzling funds of the company “Kirovles” (five-year prison sentence), entered into force in October last year.
How sawing in “Gazprom”
Perhaps the first, caused quite a stir, blog entry Alexei Navalny (several hundred references, more than 100 thousand views in a few days), is the story with the headline “How sawing in” Gazprom “, which was published in late December 2008. It Navalny, who, as a shareholder of “Gazprom”, by the time officially recognized and the victim and civil plaintiff, described the scheme of multi-million dollar embezzlement in the purchase of gas. In short: “Mezhregiongaz” (a 100 per cent subsidiary of “Gazprom”) through an intermediary “Transinvestgaz” bought gas from a small company “Novatek” – at a price three times higher than that a few days earlier “Novatek” offered “Gazprom”. According to Navalny, approximately $ 10 million difference, remaining at “Transinvestgaza”, as a result of settled in the pockets of top managers “Mezhregiongaz”.
In March 2009, Alexey Navalny said that the accused in a criminal case initiated on the facts of the theft of money from “Mezhregiongaz”, became the sixth man. Including the deputy general director of “Mezhregiongaz” Igor Dmitriev and former CEO and chief accountant of “Trastinvestgaz.” They were accused of abuse of power with serious consequences and causing damage to property by an organized group on a large scale. In May of this criminal case (№116372) withdrawn from the production of the investigator GUS in the Moscow police and handed over to the Investigation of the Main Directorate of the Russian Interior Ministry in the Central Federal District, which two months later decided to stop the prosecution of Igor Dmitriev. Learning of this, Alexei Navalny urged readers of his blog to require law enforcement officials for clarification. As a result, the Ministry of Internal Affairs received 512 formal complaints, the decision to dism iss the case was reversed, the case was transferred to another investigator, and Bulk start acting on behalf of the shareholders of “Gazprom” (total number of shares – about 530 thousand units). However, despite all efforts, by the end of 2009, this criminal case completely collapsed.
How sawing in VTB
In November 2009, Navalny’s blog there is another, which brought thousands of views and hundreds of census record “How sawing in VTB.” This time it was the acquisition of the company “VTB-Leasing” (VTB daughter of one of the largest Russian banks, 85 per cent state-owned) drilling rigs for subsequent lease. Alexei Navalny found out that expensive equipment managers bought not directly from the manufacturer, to provide, to his knowledge, such a possibility, and at the Cyprus mediator with a 50 per cent premium. According to Navalny, these settings VTB has not leased – 4.5 thousand wagons of equipment taken on the Yamal Peninsula and left in an open field.
The video, filmed on the grounds of fasting for a few days, gathered 70 thousand display. Navalny again supported the readers of his blog and other minority shareholders of VTB. Investigators then refused to open a criminal case at the request of Alexei Navalny, then again, under pressure from prosecutors and bloggers back to check. More than two years Alexei Navalny and associates tried to bring the case of rigs to court, but to no avail. However, in June of 2011 at the annual meeting of shareholders of VTB president Andrei Kostin called the deal of the problem and said the dismissal of several managers to deal with it. Law enforcement agencies of the offense in this story is not found.
But by mid-2010 the investigators who seem dopekli complaints and claims Navalny contrive that one test or the other, decided to test him.
In June 2010, “Rossiyskaya Gazeta” reported that “the law enforcement agencies of the Volga Federal District, with the support of the FSB is checked into the involvement of well-known blogger in gray schemes in the forest complex Vyatka region.” Then for the first time in the national press were beside the name of “Bulk” and the name “Kirovles”.
How sawing in “Transneft”
By the end of 2010 year Runet discuss a new investigation Navalny. This time, he spoke about “How sawing in” Transneft “. The blog has published a document containing information about the embezzlement worth more than 120 billion rubles in the project pipeline system” Eastern Siberia – Pacific Ocean “(ESPO), which deals with “Transneft”. It turned out that the theft, which told Bulk noticed and Russian Audit Chamber, but to justice anyone not involved, although the then head of the joint venture, and Sergei Stepashin said that the criminal case has been opened. The only known “punished” as a result turned out to be one of the auditors LLC “Transneft Finance”, which was dismissed in connection with the leak of documents.
troublemaker leadership “Transneft” Alexei Navalny began back in 2008. Soon after he found out that for previous 2007 the company spent on charity 7 billion 193 million rubles – nearly a billion more than in the repair and maintenance of all of its oil pipelines in the same year. figure out where it went so generous donations, Bulk inquired from the largest charitable and non-profit organizations Russia, but it turned out that none of them from “Transneft” money is not received, sent a request to the company itself. This story also became the subject of investigative audits, but has also been launched on the brakes, even though the court’s decision “illegal omission” of the investigation. However, the arbitration courts have upheld the right of a shareholder Navalny view the complete reporting on cash flow “Transneft”, but to get the names of the charitable organizations that received from “Transneft” 7 billion rubles, Alexey Navalny failed.
Soon after recording Navalny on the “sawing” in “Transneft” became aware of the resumption of inspections in the case of “Kirovlesa.” Of the Main Directorate of the Interior Ministry in the Volga Federal District, he was sent to the Kirov Department of the UPC, which investigators ought to find out whether Navalny, as an advisor to the governor of the Kirov region, “by deception and abuse of trust” led the former Director KOGUP “Kirovles” conclude disadvantageous for the enterprise agreement the supply of wood. Then the criminal case against Alexei Navalny was denied, and the validity of such refusal in March 2011, the Investigative Committee confirmed the Volga Federal District “due to the lack of action Navalny of evidence.” As signs of the activity Navalny on the network and protest rallies late 2011 – early 2012, the case “Kirovlesa” the investigating authorities will then stop w ith the explanation of the possibility to require rehabilitation, then again to resume. And in the midst of the election campaign for the office of mayor of Moscow, Leninsky district court Kirov recognizes Alexei Navalny guilty of fraud “Kirovlesom”.
“painting”, “RosYama”, “RosZhKH” and BCF
On the eve of the new 2011 Alexei Navalny announced the creation of the “painting”. The idea is to public control over budget spending on state and municipal procurement, purchasing state-owned companies. Here’s how he wrote about the project Navalny in his blog:
“1. All wishing to bring to the site information on public procurement tenders, having a clear raspilochny character.
2. Through the website we find and register of experts willing to help in exposing crooks.
3. The experts write the examination, the lawyers wrote in the complaint Antimonopoly Service and other agencies.
4. If you need to physically go to the commissions, courts, and so on. E., Then I do it with my colleagues “.
According to information posted on the site” painting “, project participants have found fraudulent tenders and prevent theft of over $ 59 billion rubles. And one of the latest achievements of the project was the decision of the Krasnoyarsk of the Federal Antimonopoly Service of the large cartels at auction disclosed at the request of lawyers “painting”. It has been established that the conspirators obtained unjustified income of $ 664 million. The case file handed over to the Central Investigation Department at the State Ministry of Interior of Russia in Krasnoyarsk Territory to consider bringing the guilty officials conspirators to criminal liability under Art. 178 of the Criminal Code.
In May 2011, Alexei Navalny announced the launch of yet another community project – “RosYama” in the financing of which at first Bulk (by his own admission) has invested 100 thousand rubles.
The purpose of the project – the motivation of the Russian authorities to improve the state of the roads. Users are encouraged to post pictures of the damaged road sections showing where the picture, then the system automatically generates the text of the complaint in the traffic police. If within 37 days (the period specified by the law of the complaint), the user receives no response, the system automatically generates an application which offers to send to the prosecutor. In early October 2014 collection “RosYamy” consisted of 60,935 defects, 18,256 of which are fixed.
A similar principle motivation negligent officials and used in another project Navalny – “RosZhKH.” It allows you to send to various state bodies (including in Goszhilinspektsiyu) complaints about the work of public utilities. For example, you can complain to the fact that in the entrance of the roof leaks, and the stairwells there is no light. The site contains 26 pieces of complaints about the work of public utilities. To apply enough to write your name and address and briefly describe the problem. After that, the complaint is automatically sent to several supervisory authorities. Shortly after the start of the project the main state housing inspector named Nicholas Vasjutin project Alexei Navalny attempt to “discredit the opposition forces in all levels of government.” He issued a special appeal to their subordinates, which urged them to “show restraint and understanding of the situation” in which the number of calls to the age ncy has increased significantly.
Since the foundation of “painting” and “RosYama” existed at the expense of crowdsourcing but in early 2012, Navalny said that refuses anonymous donations for the activities of their projects and to establish a fund to combat corruption (BCF) for their funding. Subsequently became known the names of a number of sponsors of the fund, including businessmen were eleven and five public figures. Including businessman Alexander Lebedev, a journalist Leonid Parfyonov, writers Grigory Chkhartishvili and Dmitry Bykov. Donations of citizens FBK takes today.
PZhiV and Rosvybory
In February 2011, the radio station “Finam-FM” Alexei Navalny called the “United Russia “” party of crooks and thieves. ” This meme in a matter of days, has become popular so that the search engine Google for “party of crooks and thieves,” the first in the list of found gave a link to the website of “United Russia”.
So unflattering review of the ruling party turned to Alexei Navalny lawsuit. United Russia, Vladimir Svirid considered that meme “party of crooks and thieves” denigrates his honor, dignity and business reputation. He demanded Navalny denials and non-pecuniary damages (1 million rubles). However Lublin Svirida lawsuit dismissed in its entirety.
Meanwhile, Alex Bulk announced in his blog about the beginning of a large-scale campaign “Come to the polls and vote for any party against the United Russia – the party of crooks and thieves.” The campaign took place competitions EdRo-poster and music videos, calling the following statements slogan that made the blog Navalny even more popular in RuNet.
In the wake of protest activity related to citizen dissatisfaction scale fraud in the parliamentary elections of 2011 Alexei Navalny launches another project – “RosVybory.” The aim of the project – to organize supervise the voting on those areas where “committed obvious fraud in the previous elections”.
And in May 2012, there is “Good car truth” (DMP) – a project in which produces a registration to “fight with the state propaganda machine” and provided for the dissemination of materials containing criticism of corrupt officials and the authorities and the “United Russia”. One of the first actions of DMP was distributing leaflets, talks about inflating the prices of utility services in Russia.
“Pan Bastrykin”
The head of the Investigative Committee of Russia Alexander Bastrykin – “foreign agent” wrote in July 2012, his blog Alexei Navalny. Here he leads photocopies of official documents, from which it follows that in 2007 and 2008 (that is, even during the civil service), the then Deputy Prosecutor General of Russia having a residence permit in the Czech Republic and was the founder of the company, which owns an apartment in Prague. Navalny said that Bastrykin, being a high-ranking official with access to state secrets, for many years hiding in their declarations of income and property availability of real estate and residence in the country – a member of NATO.
This article was a lot of feedback: theme picked up by both Russian and major Western publications. As a result of numerous journalistic investigations revealed that a large Russian government official Bastrykin owned real estate not only in the Czech Republic, but also in Spain. Navalny and his team from BCF messages sent statements of the facts in the Russian presidential administration (demanding the resignation Bastrykina), the Investigative Committee and the FSB. However, the career of Alexander Bastrykin is not affected. He told the newspaper “Izvestia” said an apartment of 46 square meters acquired in 2000, as was going to be engaged in teaching in European universities. Firm Law Bohemia, the founder of which he was allowed to receive long-term Bastrykin Czech visa, “rather than a residence permit.” In the end, the company and its affiliated apartment were transferred Bastrykin Natalia – head of the UK’s first wife, with whom the y are “for 22 years not living”.
“Pehting”
Zamoskvoretskiy Moscow district court announced the verdict brothers Navalny. Oleg court appointed 3.5 years of imprisonment. Alex sentenced to the same term, but conditional. Political analysts believe that the sentence indicates a desire to reduce the power of protest wave, and brother Navalny called hostage.
Early in the morning the building Zamoskvoreche Court of Moscow besieging crowd of wishing to get on the trial of Navalny. The police put up a cordon around the court, and on the surrounding streets have built a system of barriers. In the event of detention were on duty in front of the three bus service.
In the crowd wanting to get to the sentencing was also Oleg Navalny. He went to court in a cap-balaclava covering the face.
From the side looked like this: a man with a closed face and Balaklava great Baul in the hands shouted, “Let me go to my court ! “- and tried to break through the cordon.
The mask has attracted the attention of law enforcement. Police officers rushed into the crowd, literally dragged the man to the territory of the court through the fence and pulled the balaclava. Apparently recognizing the delayed Oleg Navalny, immediately released.
Alexei Navalny, who took with him as the verdict bag with things in the courthouse was without incident.
Despite the bitter cold on the street Tatar formed a small support group of brothers. People were chanting “Freedom! Freedom! “. Police officers were pushing them Tatar street to the Garden Ring and through the speaker urged the crowd to “liberate the roadway and do not interfere with the movement of vehicles».
Meanwhile, Judge Elena Korobchenko proceeded to verdict was announced.
“Oleg Navalny found guilty. Sentenced him to 3 years and 6 months imprisonment in a penal colony. Taken into custody in the courtroom. Serving the sentence read from December 30, 2014 “- read a paper by Judge Korobchenko.
Charges brothers produce on the same articles of the Criminal Code, but Alexis was waiting for a much more lenient sentence. Court appointed him 3.5 years probation.
The verdict has caused a strong reaction Alexei Navalny.
«What are planting brother? What a disgusting ?! “- Alexei Navalny shouted. At this time, police officers already dressed in his brother’s handcuffs.
As it became known later, Oleg Navalny from the court taken to jail №2 (Butyrskaya).
«It the worst of the sentence that may be – said, coming out on the porch of the court, Alexei Navalny. – We see that the government is not even just trying to destroy political opponents and put them – this is a familiar situation. This time they kill and torture the relatives of his political opponents ».
a sentence does not end there. Both brothers were fined 500 thousand. Rub. In addition, in a civil lawsuit, they are obliged to pay 4.4 million rubles. “Multidisciplinary processing company”, which, according to investigators, along with “Yves Rocher” affected by the activities of Navalny.
Sentencing lasted about 10 minutes. Judge Elena Korobchenko read out only the introductory and the operative part (ie the court decision without disclosing the reasoning part). Plenum of the Supreme Court allows such a procedure when considering the difficult economic criminal cases. The reason for such a brief announcement of the judge did not explain, but we already know that the full version of the judgment the parties can get in the next year – 12 January.
The lawyers called the verdict Alexei Navalny surprisingly soft. Suspended sentence he had received in the case of “Kirovlesa”, a new term does not add on. This is due to the fact that the embezzlement “Yves Rocher”, according to investigators, occurred before the embezzlement “Kirovlesa.” Korobchenko judge explained that the new sentence is considered a separate, and the appointment of two parallel suspended sentence allowed by law.
lawyer Alexei Navalny Olga Mikhailova noted that the judge during sentencing reclassified accusation brothers Navalny on the softer article.
Earlier investigation imputed an offense under Part 4 of Article 159 (fraud). However, the court considered the accusation inaccurate. According to Judge Korobchenko, Bulk committed a crime in the commercial sphere, then charged under Article 159 of the Criminal Code has become charged under Article 159.4 of the Criminal Code (fraud in business). This offense in the Penal Code appeared relatively recently – in 2012, so it’s not very widely used. The penalty for this article provided a softer – a fine of up to 1.5 million rubles. or up to 5 years in prison.
Protection intends soon to appeal the verdict. According to Olga Mikhailova, lawyers will be able to do so only after receiving the text of the sentence in his hands. By law, it will have 10 days. Prior to the consideration of the appeal Alexei Navalny will remain under house arrest, all the days that will be considered and counted as serving probation.
Do not rule out appeal and state prosecution, but that the representatives of the prosecutor’s office will also have to wait for the full text of the sentence.
Protection of Oleg Navalny and did believe that he was illegally taken into custody in the courtroom.
The lawyers have filed this complaint, stating that economic article does not change the measure of restraint to the defendant to appeal to a higher court, in this case – in the Moscow City Court. This was reported by the lawyer Olga Mikhailova. Press Secretary Zamoskvoreche Court confirmed that the complaint was filed.
The lawyer Vladimir foal in the comments “Gazeta.ru” Navalny called the verdict “far from the legal field».
«The court has the right to read only the introductory and the operative part of the judgment. Also, the law was taking Oleg Navalny in custody in the courtroom. This execution of the sentence of imprisonment. Otherwise, everything that is connected with the bulk due to some political expediency, and all this is far from the legal field. It is unclear why Alexey appoint a suspended sentence, and Oleg – real time. Older brother already has a suspended sentence, but he was not sentenced to real term. And his brother, convicted for the first time, sentenced just really. Alexei like to educate want. Once conditionally, second, third. There is such a thing as the rule of law. But in this case it does not work. Therefore, to predict what will be the result of the appeal, it is impossible “, – said the foal.
It is worth noting that a suspended sentence Alexei Navalny was expected. According to the “Gazety.Ru”, on Monday, the day before sentencing, close to the Kremlin experts predict recommended probation in interviews with the media. Kremlin-connected opinion leaders like Christine Patupchyk also wrote confidently in social networks about a suspended sentence.
Now politicians repeat one word – a hostage. Chapter “Political expert group” Konstantin Kalachev believes that the Russian government does not like to take risks. Because prefer not to deprive him of his liberty to do “martyr on trumped-up charges” in the crisis, says expert.
«Someone, perhaps it would be more easy to hide Navalny for three years, but people make decisions weigh the pros and cons. Selected inertial scenario. Russian Nelson Mandela is not needed. The opposition said the Kremlin feared. But it’s the lesser of two evils. If we consider the situation as a purely domestic, the tactics of the authorities is simple: real terms of ordinary participants in the demonstration process condescending attitude to the leader of the opposition. If in the general context, then the financial market, and business, and the West receive certain signals. Not the most pessimistic, “- says the analyst.
Kalachev predicts that figure now Alexei Navalny can be used in intra-disassembly. “It is, however, noted that this campaign several hurt by the fact that his brother Alexei Navalny actually taken hostage – says Kalachev. – Yesterday I did not exclude a suspended sentence. As a kind gift of Santa Claus. How to release steam. As an excuse to start a new phase of the campaign to discredit Navalny – lzhelider, a false prophet, priest Gapon, a puppet of one of the towers of the Kremlin. This is suggested by yesterday’s well-organized activity of pro-Kremlin bloggers predicting that Navalny not plant ».
Chapter” Petersburg policy “Mikhail Vinogradov thinks that the opposition remains a powerful incentive for moral protest, although emotional tension is inevitable reduced in comparison to yesterday evening. “But supporters of government remains the possibility to move the thesis that Navalny arranged behind it someone from the Kremlin,” – says the expert.
Deputy Director of the Center for Political Technologies, Alexei Makarkin says that sentence indicates a desire to reduce the power of protest wave.
According to the logic of power, his brother Alexei Navalny people do not take to the streets because it is not a political figure. “At the same time the desire to once again” hang “Alexei Navalny. His brother, who decides on a sentence, not interested. On appeal, everything is possible, and can reduce the time, but this is a real term with being in prison – said Makarkin. – All proceedings against Navalny have one feature: it is not clear who suffered. And “Yves Rocher” has no claim, and those who has fired. The administration of the Kirov region have no complaints about the “Kirovlesa” and former leaders of SPS claims have. And from the point of view of political supporters and opponents of Alexei Navalny convinced of their rightness. Opponents say: “he was a swindler, and his brother-convict.” And supporters once again convince political engagement process ».
Interestingly, parallel sentencing Prosecutor General’s Office acknowledged the last word Alexei Navalny” extremist material ».