Wednesday, December 24, 2014

The verdict in the case of a disaster at HPP: satisfied lawyers, unhappy family – Moskovsky Komsomolets

The verdict in the case of a disaster at HPP: satisfied lawyers, unhappy family – Moskovsky Komsomolets

«MK” figured out how to react to the verdict in the families of the victims

Today, at 16:38, Views: 6605

Sayanogorsky City Court of Khakassia announced the verdict in the case of the largest man-made disaster at the Sayano-Shushenskaya HPP. Then on August 17, 2009, killing 75 people from three hundred, who were at the station.

The former station director Nicholas Nevolko as Chief Engineer Andrei Mitrofanov sentenced to six years in a penal colony. Former deputy chief engineer Eugene Shervarli and Gennady Nikitenko received 5.5 years and 5 years and 9 months, respectively. Former employees of service monitoring equipment HPP Alexander Matviyenko and Alexander Klyukach sentenced to 3 and 5 years of imprisonment, their counterpart Vladimir Byeloborodov pardoned.

Special correspondent “MK” learned how to react to verdict victims.

& # x41F; & # x440; & # x438; & # x433; & # x43E; & # x432; & # x43E; & # x440; & # x43F; & # x43E; & # x434; & # x435; & # x43B ; & # x443; & # x43E; & # x43A; & # x430; & # x442; & # x430; & # x441; & # x442; & # x440; & # x43E; & # x444; & # x435; & # x43D; & # x430; & # x413; & # x42D; & # x421 ;: & # x434; & # x43E; & # x432; & # x43E; & # x43B; & # x44C; & # x43D; & # x44B; & # x44E; & # x440; & # x438; & # x441; & # x442; & # x44B ;, & # x43D; & # x435; & # x434; & # x43E; & # x432; & # x43E ; & # x43B; & # x44C; & # x43D; & # x44B; & # x440; & #    x43E; & # x434; & # x43D; & # x44B; & # x435; < P> Photo: Mikhail Kovalev

Six months ago, a lawyer representing the injured party Galina Romanovsky to the question, how long can get the defendants, said:

-In one article that they face – up to seven years in prison. May be taken into account health, retirement age, the positive characteristics, awards, and real imprisonment will not. I think that the issue of “plant not planted” is no longer relevant. The main thing that was definitely a guilty verdict – the edification of posterity, that such a disaster will not happen again.

Do not helped any awards or certificates. The court sentenced the defendants in the case to the actual terms of imprisonment.

‘I think that the sentence is absolutely legitimate and fair, – says Galina now Romanov. – I think he is completely satisfied with the victims. When I spoke in the debate, reflect that Klyukach, Matvienko and Beloborodov, should be sentenced to the proportionality of their guilt.

Why Vladimir Beloborodov was pardoned?

-Because he retired, he was already 70 years old. Here it is worth considering. Place of whether 70 – year specialists at high risk?

-Figuranty cases were that they give so much?

‘I think those two, Nevolko and Shervarli that from September 9 in custody of – for violations of the recognizance not to leave, expecting that they will be given a real prison terms. When they were taken into custody in the fall, and all the others seem to understand that the punishment will be severe enough.

-Im be counted upon arrest?

-Log only real prison time. This applies only to Nevolko Shervarli. In Detention they were on September 9, three months in jail with little to them and zachtutsya. The rest will be fully serve their sentences. Another thing is that considering how they will behave, they can replace serve their sentence in a penal colony on koloniyu- settlement.

The Chairman of the Committee for Protection of victims in the accident at the Sayano-Shushenskaya HPP “Steps to Life” Nikolai Zholob, who lost his son in the man-made disaster, in turn, says:

– We are not happy with the verdict. Why did not answer for the tragedy of those who were listed in his report to the parliamentary committee? Why not sit on the bench defendants top managers from leading companies?

-You were themselves at sentencing?

-Was in the hall, but occasionally out . Hard to us all relive. More than five years on we go, pull the sick. A Nevolko with Mitrofanov after serving for three years and will be released. Already them something in the area will provide acceptable conditions, money nowadays all rule. Most importantly, none of those who sat in the dock, pleaded not guilty, repented not brought us an apology. Now going to appeal, but I think that the prosecution would agree with the court. And how do we live? I buried the last remains of his son a year ago, in 2013. A top reported that all buried with honors …

I remember the city of energy Cheryomushki in mourning, when five years ago, with lower elevations flooded the station every day, getting out all the new bodies of power engineers. Death toll was 75. Local -76 believe, one of the women was six months pregnant. She was so happy when the ultrasound showed that the boy should be born … Machines with coffins then stretched for several kilometers. All the women in the village were in black shawls.

Some are time heals, other cripples. If the mothers of dead sons still calling: remember those who paid with their lives for the shed on the settlement “golden rain”, the women who lost their husbands in the accident, trying to pull away from the tragedy.

Of the 19 widows are now 17 minor children. Seven of them are made now in a new marriage, four families were children together.

In memory of those killed at the foot of the station built a chapel. The doors are not closed. Go, put a candle in front of icons can be anyone.

Hydropower is often seen near the chapel Anatoly Zhdanov, who lost in the crash of a 27-year-old son Vyacheslav. His body was found in the Yenisei, only 9 of September. Master, who escaped, recalled how from hydroelectric flew whistling whopper rotor began to spin like a top, and out of the hole as from a volcano, water gushed up. Glory as the driver Alexei Lalyko, sucked into a crater.

‘I remember each of the victims – says Eldar Bagautdinov working at the station advisor. – Sometimes a walk in front of man trying to learn some of the guys who left …

August 17, 2009, at the time of the accident, when the panic and individual workers rushed to their foreign cars to get away from the station, the chief engineer GES Bagautdinov pulled with the team on top of the dam. It was necessary to prevent the flooding of settlements.

Automation has failed. Manually, using only mechanical equipment, they lowered the 150-ton hydraulic units valves conduits, thereby stopping the flow of water under high pressure in the turbine hall. Eldar Bagautdinov was awarded the Order of Courage and won a name Vysotsky “Own Track».

The cause of the accident at the Sayano-Shushenskaya HPP acknowledged destruction of fasteners. Cover for emergency hydraulic unit №2 was attached with special metal pins with a diameter of 8 cm, which was 80 pieces. On SSHPP they never replaced. Laboratory and visual studies have shown that some of the pins were worn hydraulic unit by 95%, some 30%, some half.

The investigation into the accident at the Sayano-Shushenskaya HPP lasted four years, almost half of the year were the hearings. Were collected in 1213 volumes of documents, interviewed 300 witnesses, conducted 234 examinations. As the head of the Prosecutor’s Office of Khakassia Svetlana Kisurkina, “not all the volumes of the criminal case were announced, and only evidence that is considered necessary».

victim status recognized 162 people. At the hearings came to 10-12 people. Valentine Garntseva, which is now three children of his deceased daughter Ina at the station, said: “In court, I did not go. Where do I? One grandson from school come, another must be in kindergarten take the third is sick. ” Her daughter, Inna Zholobova-Garntseva and stayed 35 years. After the decree had time to work as a plasterer-painter all year. When flooded the station, she was found among the first.

75-year-old Alexander Ivanov complained: “refuses and heart, and legs. In court I do not go, it is useless. ” In the accident at the hydroelectric she lost her only 49-year-old daughter. Adults granddaughter went to live in Krasnoyarsk.

There was a court hearing and Elena Malik. Lena admitted: “It is hard every time to relive the tragedy. I think that those who are actually guilty, punished a higher power. ” Elena in the “black” Thursday killed her husband, who worked as a foreman of a turbine plant. Got it on the fifth day, when the water pumped out at around 315. Now she is raising her son and daughter.

And sellers bookstore shared with us that in recent years there has been increased demand for books on psychology and the occult literature. Villagers became interested in “life after death”. Many around now perceive mystical phenomena.

-Avariya happened on the day of the memory of the martyrs of Ephesus – Christians who, according to legend, were buried alive in the rock, and after a few centuries out of there alive, – whispers Anna, whose son died in this terrible accident. – Our, station guys, too, were walled up in the concrete under water bag … When the cemetery opened a chapel, named it in honor of the martyrs of Ephesus.

LikeTweet

No comments:

Post a Comment